Operators' Playbook22 July 2026 · 13 min read

Stocky alternatives: what Shopify replaced, and what it didn't

Stocky stopped working on 31 August. Shopify's admin now does purchase orders and suppliers, so the paperwork moved. The judgement didn't: the question of what to order, and when, now belongs to nobody unless you give it to someone.

Konstantinos Gkolias

Konstantinos Gkolias

Founder, building Lumnya

Operators' Playbook

After Stocky, who decides?

Lumnyaai

First published 22 July 2026, six weeks before the shutdown; rewritten 19 October 2026, seven weeks after it. Shopify's help page said it plainly: “The Stocky app will no longer be available after August 31st, 2026.” That date has passed. If you used Stocky, you have already moved somewhere, even if “somewhere” is a spreadsheet and your memory. If you're looking for a Stocky alternative, this guide is for the weeks after the move: what Shopify actually replaced, the part it didn't, and how to do that part yourself this afternoon, whatever tool you landed on.

  • Shopify's admin now does purchase orders and suppliers natively: drafts, ordered status, supplier terms and currencies, and receiving stock through a linked transfer. The paperwork moved.
  • What did not move is Stocky's judgement: the demand-based suggestions that told you what to order and when. Its min/max forecasting had already been removed in July 2025.
  • Without that layer, most stores fall back to ordering when something runs out. With a 14-day lead time, that alone can mean two weeks sold out on a bestseller.
  • The fix is old and cheap: a reorder point per product, built from your sales, your supplier's worst recent lead time, and a safety stock. The worked method and a figure you can copy are below.
  • We say exactly where Lumnya helps today and where it doesn't. Short version: it watches stock daily against thresholds you set; it does not do purchase orders, supplier records or velocity-based forecasts yet.

What Shopify replaced, and what it didn't

The good news first. Shopify's own purchase orders now live in the admin. You can create and manage suppliers with contact details, payment terms and currencies; save an order as a draft or mark it as ordered once the supplier confirms; and receive the stock through an inventory transfer created from the order, with cost adjustments on the way in. For a lot of stores, that covers what Stocky was used for day to day.

What Stocky didWhere it lives nowNotes
Purchase ordersShopify admin, freeDraft and ordered statuses; receiving happens through a linked transfer.
Supplier recordsShopify admin, freeContact details, payment terms, currencies. Stocky never let you export its own supplier records, so many stores had to rebuild these by hand.
Receiving stockShopify admin, via transfersStock updates when the transfer is received.
Transfers between locationsShopify adminAlready removed from Stocky in July 2025.
Demand-based reorder suggestionsNowhere by defaultThe planning layer. A dedicated app, a spreadsheet, or you.
Min/max forecastingNowhere by defaultAlready removed from Stocky in July 2025.

Read the last two rows again, because they are the whole point of this piece. The forms moved: you can still write, send and receive an order. The decision that comes before the form, which product, how many, and why now, has no default owner any more. In Stocky it was a suggestion you could accept or ignore. In a plain admin it is a blank field and a question you have to remember to ask.

The shutdown moved the forms. It didn't move the decision.

What happens when nobody owns the decision

When there is no reorder point, stores reorder the way people naturally do: when they notice something is low, which in practice means when it is nearly gone. That works for products your supplier delivers tomorrow. It fails for everything else, and it fails in a specific, predictable way: the stockout lasts as long as the lead time. Order on the day you sell out, and you are sold out until the delivery arrives.

Figure 1 · Two ways to reorder the same product

Ordering at a reorder point never runs dry. Ordering when it runs out costs you the lead time.

One product selling 4 a day from 120 in stock, with a supplier who takes 14 days to deliver.

Ordering when it runs outOrdering at the reorder point
Illustrative product: 4 sales a day, 14-day lead time, safety stock 25, order quantity 100. The method is real; the numbers are an example.

Nothing about the product changed between the two lines. Same sales, same supplier, same order size. The only difference is when the decision was made, and the difference shows up as two weeks of a sold-out bestseller in the example (the full lead time), more if the supplier is late. That is what Stocky's suggestions were quietly doing for you, and what now has to be done some other way.

The reorder point, done properly

You can rebuild the missing judgement in a spreadsheet. The formula is decades old and still the right starting point:

Reorder point = average daily sales × lead time in days + safety stock. For safety stock, a practical start is the gap between your busiest recent week and an average one: (peak daily sales − average daily sales) × lead time. When a product's stock touches its reorder point, you order.

ProductAvg daily salesLead timeSafety stockReorder point
Nordic Hoodie / M4.214 days2584
Aurora Mug, 4-pack1.530 days1560
Trail Socks, 3-pack7.07 days2170

Illustrative numbers, real method. Three details turn it from a formula into a habit that works.

  • Use the worst recent lead time, not the average. Safety stock exists for the bad month. A supplier who usually takes 14 days and sometimes takes 21 needs a reorder point built for 21. Figure 2 shows how much that moves the number.
  • Work per variant, not per product. The medium hoodie and the extra-large are different businesses. A product-level reorder point lets the popular size sell out while the total looks healthy.
  • Recompute monthly. A reorder point set in July and never touched is how January stockouts happen. Seasonality is the most common reason a good number goes bad.

Figure 2 · The lead time you plan for

Planning for the worst recent lead time raises every reorder point, often by a third

Reorder points for the three example products, using the supplier's average lead time and its worst recent one.

Nordic Hoodie / M · 4.2 a day

  • Average lead time · 14 days84
  • Worst recent · 21 days113

Aurora Mug, 4-pack · 1.5 a day

  • Average lead time · 30 days60
  • Worst recent · 40 days75

Trail Socks, 3-pack · 7 a day

  • Average lead time · 7 days70
  • Worst recent · 10 days91
Illustrative products from the table above. Worst-case lead times: hoodie 21 days, mug 40 days, socks 10 days.

Safety stock: your supplier matters more than your customers

The simple safety-stock rule above, (peak daily sales − average) × lead time, is deliberately rough. It is worth knowing what the textbook version says, because it changes where you should spend your attention.

The standard formula sizes safety stock for two kinds of uncertainty at once: how much daily sales vary, and how much the supplier's lead time varies. For a service level of about 95% (stock out in roughly one replenishment cycle in twenty), it is 1.65 × √(lead time × variation in daily sales² + average daily sales² × variation in lead time²), with variation measured as a standard deviation. You don't need to compute it often. You need to see what it implies.

Figure 3 · What sets the safety stock

For a typical small store, the supplier's unreliability sets the safety stock, not the customers'

Safety stock for the Nordic Hoodie (4.2 sales a day, varying by 1.5; a 14-day lead time that varies by 3 days), three ways.

Safety stock, units

  • Sales variation only9
  • Sales and lead-time variation23
  • Simple rule: (peak − average) × lead time25
Worked example. Standard safety-stock formula at z = 1.65 (about 95% cycle service level); standard deviations: daily sales 1.5 units, lead time 3 days.

Two things follow. First, the rough rule is not bad: for this product it lands within a couple of units of the textbook answer, which is why it is a fine place to start. Second, and more useful: most of the safety stock is there because of the supplier, not the shoppers. Demand noise alone would justify 9 units. A lead time that wobbles by three days adds 14 more. For many small stores, the cheapest way to hold less stock is not a better forecast. It is a supplier who delivers when they say they will, or a conversation with the one who doesn't.

A 20-minute weekly routine

  • Monday, 5 minutes: sort your catalogue by days of cover, lowest first. Anything at or below its lead time plus safety days gets a purchase order this week.
  • Monday, 5 minutes: for every order that arrived last week, note the actual lead time next to the promised one. This is the column that will tell you where your safety stock really comes from.
  • First Monday of the month, 10 minutes more: recompute average daily sales per variant over the last 30 days, and update the reorder points. Use the worst lead time from your notes.
  • Whenever a supplier is late twice: raise their lead time in the sheet. Don't wait for the monthly review; the next order is already exposed.

Days of cover: the one number to look at each morning

A reorder point is a threshold. Days of cover is the same idea as a countdown, and it is easier to read at a glance: current stock divided by average daily sales. Forty hoodies selling 4.2 a day is about nine and a half days of cover. Compare it with the lead time: when days of cover falls to the lead time plus a few days of safety, you order.

The reason to look at days of cover rather than units is that it makes products comparable. Twenty mugs and twenty pairs of socks look the same on a stock report. At 1.5 and 7 sales a day, one has thirteen days left and the other has three. Sort your catalogue by days of cover, ascending, and the top of the list is your purchasing for the week.

Stocky alternatives: your options, honestly

OptionStrongest whenWatch out for
Shopify's admin (purchase orders, suppliers, transfers)You need the paperwork and you're happy to make the reorder decision yourself, with a spreadsheet like the one above.No demand-based suggestions: the judgement is entirely yours.
Dedicated inventory apps (Inventory Planner, Prediko, Fabrikatör and similar)Forecasting and purchasing are the centre of your week. These are mature, purpose-built tools.Another tool with its own learning curve. Check that you can see the numbers behind its suggestions.
ERP / WMS platformsYou are multi-channel and multi-warehouse, with operations to match.Months to implement and priced accordingly. Overkill for most former Stocky stores.
Lumnya (that's us)You want stock watched daily as part of one system that also answers your customers, and acts only with your approval.Private beta. Threshold alerts, not demand forecasts; no purchase orders or supplier records. Details below.

Whatever you choose, use this as a test: can you see the numbers behind its suggestions? A recommendation to reorder 120 units should come with the sales rate, the lead time and the safety stock it assumed. If it can't show you those, you are being asked to trust a black box with your cash flow.

Five questions before you trust an app's reorder suggestions

If you choose a dedicated inventory app for the planning layer, you are handing it the decision Stocky used to make. Before you do, put these to the vendor, or test them yourself in the trial. They separate a planning tool from a dashboard with a reorder button.

  • “What sales window does a suggestion use, and can I change it?” Thirty days, ninety, the same month last year? A tool that can't tell you is averaging something you can't see.
  • “Which lead time does it assume: the one I typed, or the one my suppliers actually delivered?” The second is worth far more, for the reason Figure 3 shows.
  • “Does it work per variant?” If it plans at product level, your best-selling size will run out while the product total looks healthy.
  • “How does it handle a product that was out of stock?” Days with zero stock have zero sales. A naive average reads that as low demand and orders less, which causes the next stockout. Good tools exclude those days.
  • “Can I see the safety stock it used, in units?” If the suggestion arrives as a single number with no parts, you can't tell a cautious tool from a careless one.

Where Lumnya fits, and where it doesn't yet

Lumnya gives a Shopify store its own ecommerce AI agents: an assistant that answers your customers, and a team of specialist agents behind it. One of them, the Inventory Forecaster, is built to check your stock every day against thresholds you set (critical, low and healthy), flags the products that cross them, and suggests a reorder quantity with the reason stated. Nothing it suggests runs on its own.

Here is what it does not do today, plainly. It doesn't forecast from your sales rate yet: its suggestions come from your thresholds, not from days of cover. It doesn't create purchase orders or keep supplier records, so accepting a reorder suggestion doesn't place an order anywhere; you still do that in Shopify. If demand-based reordering is what you need right now, use a dedicated inventory app, keep the spreadsheet above alongside it, and judge us again when we get there. If one accountable system that watches your store and asks before it acts is the direction you want, the waitlist is open.

Mistakes we see after the shutdown

  • Treating native purchase orders as planning. A purchase order records a decision. It doesn't make one.
  • Reorder points set once. They go stale with the season. Recompute monthly.
  • Planning for the average supplier. Use the worst recent lead time. The average month doesn't cause stockouts.
  • Product-level thresholds on variant-level demand. The size that sells out first is the one that matters.
  • Discarding the Stocky exports. If you exported purchase-order and stocktake history before the shutdown, keep it. Shopify's help page doesn't describe any read-only access after 31 August, so don't count on getting it back.

For the peak itself, see the Black Friday reorder check; for stock that won't move, clearing dead stock without a store-wide sale; and for what shoppers want that you don't carry, counting unmet demand.

Frequently asked questions

Is Stocky still available?

No. Shopify's help page states that the Stocky app is no longer available after 31 August 2026, and it was removed from the Shopify App Store on 2 February 2026. Shopify directs merchants to its built-in inventory management features.

What is the best Stocky alternative?

It depends on which part of Stocky you relied on. For purchase orders, suppliers and receiving, Shopify's admin now covers it for free. For demand-based reorder suggestions, you need a dedicated inventory app or your own reorder points, because Shopify's admin doesn't make those suggestions.

Does Shopify have purchase orders now?

Yes. You can create purchase orders in the Shopify admin, manage suppliers with contact details, payment terms and currencies, mark orders as ordered, and receive stock through a linked inventory transfer.

How do I calculate a reorder point?

Average daily sales × lead time in days + safety stock. Use the supplier's worst recent lead time rather than the average, work per variant, and recompute monthly. For example, 4.2 sales a day, a 14-day lead time and a safety stock of 25 gives a reorder point of 84.

Does Lumnya replace Stocky?

Partly. Lumnya's Inventory Forecaster is built to check stock daily against thresholds you set and suggest reorders, all in private beta. It does not create purchase orders, keep supplier records or forecast from sales velocity yet. Use Shopify's admin for orders, and a dedicated app if you need demand forecasting now.

Sources

  • [1] Shopify Help Center, Stocky (accessed 19 Oct 2026).
  • [2] Shopify Help Center, Purchase orders (accessed 19 Oct 2026).
  • [3] Shopify Help Center, Inventory (accessed 19 Oct 2026).
  • [4] Lumnya product behaviour described here was verified in Lumnya's source code on 19 October 2026: the Inventory Forecaster's daily threshold check, merchant-set thresholds, and the absence of purchase orders, supplier records and velocity forecasting.

Lumnya is a team of ecommerce AI agents for Shopify stores, now in private beta. Join the waitlist.

Comments

…

Every comment is read and approved by a human before it appears — the same confirm-gated rule the product runs on.

Loading comments…

Filed under Operators' Playbook

All posts

Keep reading

Operators' Playbook

Multiply before you reorder

Lumnyaai

Black Friday inventory planning: your days of stock are an October number

12 min read · Operators' Playbook

Operators' Playbook

Clear stock, not your prices

Lumnyaai

Clear dead stock before Black Friday without teaching shoppers to wait

11 min read · Operators' Playbook

Private beta

Enough reading. See it on your store.

Join the private beta and be first in line when Lumnya opens to your store.